Comparison

Proctorly vs Mercer | Mettl: AI proctoring compared for 2026

Mercer | Mettl leads on breadth and scale. Proctorly leads on catching AI-era cheating and backing every flag with a person's decision and evidence.

Person on a video call at a laptop

Side-by-side comparison

Capability Proctorly Mercer | Mettl
Identity verification Face match at the start and during the exam; liveness challenge for high-stakes exams AI-based authentication and ID checks
Environment checks Locked browser plus optional Windows agent (SIA) that checks below the browser for virtual machines, remote-access tools and overlays Secure browser lockdown
AI-tool and overlay detection Yes: known generative-AI tools, AI browsers, extensions and overlays Not prominently described in public documentation
Virtual machine detection ✓Yes Not emphasised in public documentation
Hidden devices Room scan, camera and audio signals, behaviour analysis and reviewer judgement Standard webcam proctoring
Human review Every flag reviewed by a trained person with a recorded reason; 24x7 during exams Available; varies by plan
Evidence for appeals Case record with timestamps, screenshots, event history and the reviewer's decision Reporting and analytics dashboards
Assessment catalogue Exams and assessments for institutions Very broad: psychometric, aptitude, technical, behavioural and coding
Scale Scales with your LMS and SSO; integrity-focused Very high-volume delivery

Available   Not available

Mercer | Mettl details are taken from its public materials as of November 2026 and may change. Check its current documentation before deciding.

Our verdict

Choose Mercer | Mettl when a broad catalogue of assessment types or extreme scale leads your requirements. Choose Proctorly when your main concern is stopping AI-assisted cheating and defending every result with reviewed evidence.

Generative AI changed what online exam cheating looks like. A hidden phone is no longer the main worry: AI tools can read a question and draft an answer in seconds, virtual machines can hide a second computer, and remote-access tools can hand the session to someone else. This page compares two platforms institutions shortlist for that problem: Proctorly, an assessment integrity platform built around AI flags and human review, and Mercer | Mettl, a broad talent-assessment and examination suite. We make Proctorly, so we are not neutral. Mercer | Mettl is described from its own public materials; check its current documentation before you decide.

The two platforms in brief

Proctorly is built for one job: keeping online exams fair and every result defensible. AI watches for known threats, including generative-AI tools, remote-access and screen-sharing tools, virtual machines, browser extensions and overlays. A trained person reviews every flag and records a decision with a reason, and your institution makes the final call with the full record in hand. Identity is checked at the start and through the exam, with a liveness challenge for high-stakes papers. Proctorly is designed for GDPR and India’s DPDP Act. See online proctoring.

Mercer | Mettl is a cloud talent-assessment and examination platform owned by Mercer and widely used in India. Its strength is breadth: psychometric, aptitude, technical, behavioural and coding assessments, hiring workflows, AI-assisted remote proctoring and large-scale exam delivery. It states ISO 27001 certification and GDPR compliance, and it integrates with LMS, HRMS and ATS platforms.

In short: Mercer | Mettl leads on catalogue breadth and scale; Proctorly leads on the detection layers that matter for AI-era cheating, with a person behind every decision.

Why AI-era cheating is harder to catch

The hardest cheating to see now happens below the browser or just outside the camera’s view. A candidate can sit still while an AI tool reads the questions and shows answers in an overlay, or while a helper controls the screen from elsewhere. A webcam pointed at a face sees none of it. That is why Proctorly checks the operating environment as well as the camera: in a locked browser it tracks tab, window and extra-monitor events, and on Windows the optional Session Integrity Agent (SIA) looks below the browser for virtual machines, remote-access tools and overlays, sends only encrypted signals and removes itself when the exam ends. Our guide to how students cheat in online exams covers each method.

Hidden devices: what proctoring can and cannot see

Some cheating uses hardware that never touches the exam computer:

  • Pen cameras that photograph or stream the paper to a helper.
  • Smart glasses with a built-in camera or display.
  • Micro earpieces that relay answers by voice.
  • Smartwatches and second phones kept just out of frame.

No single camera catches all of these, on any platform. What works is layers: a room scan before the exam, continuous camera and audio monitoring for the signs a device is being used, behaviour patterns across the attempt, and a trained reviewer who looks at the evidence before anything reaches the candidate’s record. Our guide to what online proctoring can detect says plainly where the answer is “not on its own”.

Wider visibility has to come with responsibility. Proctorly tells candidates what is captured and why, keeps only what the exam needs and deletes it on a set schedule. See proctoring privacy.

What strong AI proctoring should do

Rather than comparing feature lists, judge any platform on five things:

  1. Verify identity with face matching and, for high-stakes exams, a liveness check, so the right person sits the exam.
  2. Check the environment below the browser for virtual machines, remote-access tools and extra monitors.
  3. Detect AI assistance, including AI tools, extensions and overlays, while the exam is running.
  4. Keep people in the loop, so a trained reviewer confirms a serious flag and honest candidates are not wrongly accused.
  5. Produce evidence that holds up: timestamps, screenshots, event history and the reviewer’s reason, ready for an appeal.

Proctorly is built around all five as its core purpose. Mercer | Mettl delivers proctoring as one part of a much broader assessment suite.

Why human review and evidence matter most

Fully automated verdicts produce false positives. A single AI flag can point at an honest candidate because of a network drop or an innocent movement, and nothing damages trust in an exam faster. At Proctorly, AI raises the flag, a trained reviewer decides with a recorded reason, and your institution makes the finding. Reviewers work 24×7 during exams, and a technical failure is never treated as misconduct. See human review proctoring.

Which one fits your exams

  • Universities and colleges defending degree results on appeal: Proctorly’s detection plus a reviewed evidence record is the stronger fit. See university exam software.
  • Certification and licensing bodies protecting the value of a credential: Proctorly, for the same reason. See certification exam proctoring.
  • Entrance exams at scale: both can serve; compare review capacity and evidence. See online entrance exams.
  • Hiring and talent assessment with psychometric and aptitude tests, or very large national and global drives: Mercer | Mettl’s catalogue and the wider Mercer ecosystem may suit you better.

Frequently asked questions

What is the main difference between Proctorly and Mercer | Mettl?

Focus. Proctorly is built to catch AI-assisted cheating and to back every flag with a reviewer’s decision and evidence. Mercer | Mettl is a broad assessment suite with established proctoring and very large delivery scale.
Can online proctoring detect smart glasses or earpieces?

Not with one camera, on any platform. It takes layers: a room scan, camera and audio monitoring for the signs a device is in use, behaviour analysis and a trained reviewer who checks the evidence.
Why does human review matter in AI proctoring?

Automated flags produce false positives. A trained reviewer confirms the serious ones so honest candidates are not penalised, and the reviewer’s reason becomes part of the evidence if a result is challenged.
Which is better for universities?

For stopping AI-assisted cheating and defending results on appeal, Proctorly is generally the stronger fit. Mercer | Mettl suits institutions that need a wide catalogue of assessment types or extreme exam-day scale.

Want to see Proctorly on one of your own exams? Watch how it works or book a demo. For the wider market, see our proctoring software comparison.

See Proctorly on your own exams.

A 30-minute Microsoft Teams meeting with a specialist for your role and country. Pick a time that suits you and get the meeting details and calendar invitation straight away.

  • 1Choose your country and a time inside our global business hours, shown in your local time.
  • 2Tell us who you are and what you would like to see.
  • 3Get your Microsoft Teams meeting link and calendar invitation at once.